Glen Cove, New York — A large-scale animal rescue operation continues on Long Island after authorities removed 155 neglected animals from a Glen Cove home, with investigators saying more cats may still be living around the property weeks after the homeowner’s arrest.
The rescue effort began after police and animal welfare officials responded to the residence on St. Andrews Lane in June. Since then, dozens of volunteers, shelters and local organizations have worked together to care for the rescued animals while authorities continue searching for any remaining cats.
Rescue Operation Continues Weeks After Arrest
According to the Nassau County Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (NCSPCA), the number of rescued animals has climbed to 155, including two dogs, since the investigation began.
When authorities first entered the property on June 8, they rescued more than 130 cats and dogs, including 43 cats that were found in critical condition.
Officials believe some cats that had indoor-outdoor access may still be wandering near the home, prompting an ongoing trapping operation.
“We have to continue to trap and come back until there is nothing to trap,” NCSPCA detective Brian Wasserman said.
“We’ll get them all.”
Animal rescue teams have continued returning to the neighborhood in hopes of locating every remaining cat.
Community Steps Up to Help Rescued Animals
With such a large number of animals needing immediate care, local rescue organizations, pet stores and adoption agencies have joined the effort.
Many of the rescued cats have already been placed into foster care while others are being prepared for adoption into permanent homes.
Several employees from the City of Glen Cove have also volunteered to foster or adopt the animals while donating food, supplies and their time to assist with the recovery effort.
“It was impossible not to want to help,” said Sue Tripp, one of the first city employees to adopt a rescued kitten.
The overwhelming community response has helped relieve pressure on local shelters caring for dozens of recovering animals.
Investigation Began After Daughter Contacted Authorities
Authorities said the investigation was launched after the homeowner’s 18-year-old daughter called 911 with concerns about the safety of her younger sister, who was living inside the home.
Investigators described finding extremely poor living conditions, including high ammonia levels that created dangerous air quality inside the residence.
Police reportedly wore protective equipment while entering the property due to the hazardous conditions.
According to investigators, one animal was found dead inside the home, while another died during transport to an animal hospital.
Court documents also alleged that food available to the animals was contaminated and drinking water was unsafe, while the two rescued dogs reportedly had no access to clean food or water.
Homeowner Faces Multiple Charges
Authorities said homeowner Alena Horbatko, 54, has pleaded guilty to 67 counts of torturing or injuring an animal, along with two counts of second-degree reckless endangerment and one count of acting in a manner injurious to a child under 17.
A judge ordered that she may not own animals while the case proceeds and also issued two stay-away orders of protection.
The Nassau County District Attorney’s Office is reportedly considering filing additional charges as investigators continue reviewing the case.
Horbatko is scheduled to return to court on August 10.
While dozens of rescued animals have already begun new lives through foster care and adoption, authorities say the mission is not over until every remaining cat has been safely recovered.
What are your thoughts on this rescue effort? Should penalties for large-scale animal neglect cases be tougher? Share your thoughts respectfully in the comments below.