Tucked inside a strip mall in Longwood, Florida, Pickles NY Deli has quietly built one of the most loyal customer bases in Central Florida. With over 1,300 Google reviews and a 4.4-star rating, this neighborhood deli is doing something right — and locals have noticed.
What Makes It Special
The moment you walk in, subway murals and classic New York deli decor set the tone. But the real draw is the food. The menu runs deep with deli staples — hot corned beef on homemade rye, a stacked Reuben, slow-cooked brisket, pastrami sandwiches, matzo ball soup, and potato pancakes.
Portions are generous. One reviewer said the Reuben alone was large enough to split between two people.
The Pickle Bar Everyone Talks About
The pickle bar is the deli’s signature touch — a selection of house-brined pickles in different flavor profiles that first-time visitors consistently call a highlight. Customers describe them as crisp, flavorful, and perfectly brined.
One mom drove her daughter out specifically to try the pickle bar. Both left happy.
Outdoor Seating That Surprises People
Most people don’t expect a charming outdoor courtyard at a strip-mall deli. Pickles NY Deli has one. Several customers who sat outside only because the inside was full ended up preferring it — one couple even compared the experience to a Paris lunch.
Worth the Drive
At least one customer drove nearly an hour just for the pastrami. That says everything.
Pickles NY Deli is located at West State Road 434 in Longwood, Florida.