Hickory, North Carolina — A long-running business dispute between two co-owners of a North Carolina furniture company ended in tragedy this week after one partner was fatally shot only hours after a judge ruled against the other in a contract-related court case.
Authorities have charged Willard Gary Black, 85, with second-degree murder in connection with the death of Robert Roger Arguelles, 59, following a confrontation at their shared business.
The shooting has shocked the local community, particularly because it came shortly after a court decision involving a financial dispute between the two men.
Court Ruling Came Hours Before Fatal Shooting
According to court records, Black and Arguelles had been involved in a legal battle stemming from a business agreement dating back several years.
The dispute centered on a financial arrangement connected to ownership of the company, Old Hickory Tannery.
Records indicate that in 2018, Black sold Arguelles a 49.9% ownership stake in the business. Arguelles later claimed he had loaned Black approximately $280,000, but alleged that only a small portion of the money had been repaid.
The two parties eventually agreed to settle the lawsuit for $310,882.74.
However, after settlement documents were submitted, Black reportedly attempted to withdraw his consent to the agreement.
On Wednesday, a judge denied that request and ordered Black to pay the previously agreed-upon amount.
Argument at Business Turns Deadly
Authorities said the fatal incident occurred later that same day at Old Hickory Tannery.
Investigators allege that Black and Arguelles became involved in an argument at the business following the court ruling.
During the confrontation, Arguelles was allegedly shot and suffered gunshot wounds to the chest and back.
Emergency responders rushed to the scene and attempted life-saving measures, but Arguelles was pronounced dead.
Police have not publicly disclosed additional details regarding the argument or what events immediately preceded the shooting.
Black was subsequently arrested and charged with second-degree murder.
Victim Remembered as Community Leader
Beyond his role as a business owner, Arguelles was also known throughout the community for his public service.
He had served as a member of the Alexander County Schools Board of Education since 2022, helping guide decisions affecting local students and families.
News of his death prompted an outpouring of grief from colleagues and community members.
District Superintendent Bill Griffin issued a statement remembering Arguelles for both his professional contributions and personal character.
15 Accused of Fraudulently Collecting $1.4M SNAP, Housing and Healthcare Benefits in Massachusetts
“An amazing father, husband, and board member who has faithfully supported our school system for almost four years.”
Griffin also expressed support for the family as they cope with the loss.
“In honor of his memory, our district fully supports and respects the family’s privacy as they navigate this profound loss.”
Investigation Continues
Authorities continue investigating the circumstances surrounding the shooting as the criminal case moves through the legal system.
Second-degree murder charges generally indicate prosecutors believe a killing was intentional but not necessarily premeditated.
Court records and witness accounts are expected to play a key role as investigators continue reviewing the incident.
For many in the community, the case serves as a tragic reminder of how personal and business conflicts can escalate with devastating consequences.
As legal proceedings continue, family members, colleagues, and community leaders are remembering Arguelles for his contributions both in business and public service.
What are your thoughts on this case? How should business disputes be resolved when tensions escalate? Share your thoughts respectfully in the comments below.